Manchester United are reportedly weighing up a sensational move to bring Scott McTominay back to Old Trafford, with a potential £60 million deal being discussed after the club openly admitted they may have made a costly mistake by allowing the midfielder to leave.
Since his departure, McTominay has gone on to thrive in Serie A with Napoli, delivering performances that have only intensified the sense of regret among United supporters and decision-makers alike.
The timing of this development could not be more telling. United are currently battling a serious squad crisis, with injuries piling up and several key players unavailable due to international duty at AFCON.
As a result, Ruben Amorim’s options have been stretched to the limit, leaving the squad looking alarmingly thin in crucial areas.
In moments like this, many fans cannot help but think back to McTominay — the dependable, hard-working midfielder who was once sold largely to ease financial pressure rather than for sporting reasons.
Since arriving in Naples, McTominay’s career has taken a dramatic upward turn. The Scottish international has enjoyed a remarkable transformation, becoming a central figure in Napoli’s success.
He played a vital role in their Scudetto-winning campaign, earning widespread praise for his consistency, physical presence, and leadership in midfield.
His individual accolades have been just as impressive, including being named Serie A Player of the Season and finishing an astonishing 18th in the Ballon d’Or rankings — achievements that few would have predicted during his final months in Manchester.
McTominay’s strong form has continued into the current season, where he has already contributed five goals and three assists.
Under the guidance of Antonio Conte, he has flourished tactically and mentally, thriving in a system that fully utilizes his strengths.
His resurgence has become a clear reminder that Manchester United may have underestimated the value of one of their own academy graduates.
Now, reports suggest that United are seriously reconsidering their decision and are eager to bring the midfielder back.
According to sources cited by CaughtOffside, Napoli are dealing with financial challenges and may be open to selling McTominay if a suitable offer arrives.
The Italian club has reportedly set their valuation at around £60 million. While Napoli would prefer to wait until the summer window, there is belief that a compelling January bid could force a rethink.
“Manchester United regret allowing Scott McTominay to leave and are exploring the possibility of re-signing him,” a source revealed. “Napoli will only enter negotiations if their £60 million valuation is met.”
However, United are not alone in tracking the situation. Premier League rivals including Tottenham Hotspur, Arsenal, and Newcastle United are all said to be monitoring McTominay’s progress closely, ready to act if an opportunity presents itself.
This growing competition could complicate United’s plans and potentially drive the price even higher.
The key question now is whether INEOS and the current United hierarchy have the resolve and ambition to correct a past misjudgment.
Bringing McTominay back would not only strengthen a struggling squad but also symbolize a willingness to admit errors and prioritize performance over balance-sheet decisions.
As United attempt to steady a turbulent season, the return of a familiar and revitalized warrior could prove to be both a tactical solution and a powerful statement of intent.
