Liverpool’s 2–0 victory over Brighton at Anfield sparked plenty of debate, not just because of the result, but due to the authority and control Liverpool showed throughout the match. From the opening whistle, the Reds looked organised, tactically sharp, and confident in their approach.
However, once the dust settled, the main conversation point extended far beyond the scoreline. One player, in particular, captured the attention of supporters, pundits, and even the Brighton camp — Federico Chiesa.
Despite only making a short appearance, Chiesa’s impact was impossible to overlook. His performance was so convincing that even Liverpool legend Jamie Carragher, known for his no-nonsense and often critical analysis, felt compelled to speak out. After the final whistle, Carragher delivered a powerful verdict that quickly spread among fans.
“From now on, Federico Chiesa has to be starting for us. I don’t care who Arne Slot leaves out — he belongs in the starting XI,” Carragher declared.
Such a bold statement from Carragher highlights just how influential Chiesa was in limited minutes. It also raised an unavoidable question: why has a player capable of such an impact not already cemented his place in the lineup under Arne Slot?
Big impact in a short spell
Although Chiesa did not start the match, his cameo was packed with energy, intelligence, and quality. From the moment he stepped onto the pitch, Liverpool’s intensity seemed to rise another level.
Relentless presence:
Carragher pointed out that Chiesa appeared to be everywhere. He pressed high up the pitch, chased down defenders, and showed a willingness to recover defensively when Liverpool lost possession. His work rate stood out immediately.
Intelligent movement:
Chiesa consistently drifted into dangerous pockets of space, stretching Brighton’s defensive structure. By occupying defenders and creating passing lanes, he made life easier for his teammates and added fluidity to Liverpool’s attacks.
Attacking contribution:
While he didn’t score, his influence was felt in the buildup play. Analysts highlighted his involvement in the sequence leading to Liverpool’s second goal, noting how his movement disrupted Brighton’s shape and opened up space.
Defensive commitment:
Under Slot, forwards are expected to work tirelessly without the ball, and Chiesa delivered exactly that. His pressing forced errors, disrupted Brighton’s rhythm, and showed discipline as well as hunger.
Why Carragher’s backing is significant
Carragher is not known for handing out praise lightly. His call for Chiesa to become an automatic starter carries serious weight and places additional pressure on Arne Slot to reconsider his attacking setup.
As Liverpool aim to maintain momentum and consistency in the Premier League, Chiesa’s energy and versatility could become a vital weapon.
Fans and opponents take notice
Liverpool supporters were quick to echo Carragher’s sentiment across social media, describing Chiesa’s cameo as “game-changing.” Many praised his directness, creativity, and unpredictability — qualities they believe Liverpool need more regularly.
Brighton felt the impact too. Head coach Fabian Hürzeler admitted after the match that his side struggled to contain Chiesa, noting that his movement repeatedly dragged players out of position and disrupted their defensive plan.
With praise coming from legends, fans, analysts, and even the opposition, the argument is growing louder: Federico Chiesa may no longer be an impact substitute — he may be a starter Liverpool can’t afford to leave out.
