A former Manchester United icon has sent shockwaves through the club’s fanbase after reportedly delivering a brutally honest verdict on one of the team’s most recent summer signings, describing the transfer as a catastrophic mistake and the worst he has ever seen in the club’s long history.
Manchester United are no strangers to questionable recruitment decisions, but according to club legend Paul Scholes, this particular signing stands alone for all the wrong reasons.
In comments that have rapidly circulated among supporters and pundits alike, the former midfielder is said to have expressed deep regret over the player’s arrival, delivering an assessment that ranks among the most severe criticisms ever directed at a United player by a former great.
Scholes, renowned for his straight-talking nature and refusal to sugarcoat his opinions, allegedly did not mince his words when discussing the signing.
He reportedly admitted that he regrets the moment the deal was completed, claiming that across the entire history of Manchester United, no other player represents a bigger transfer failure.
For Scholes, the situation goes beyond disappointment — he is said to view the deal as a complete waste of the club’s resources.
Such comments carry enormous weight given Scholes’ status at Old Trafford.
As one of the most decorated and respected midfielders the club has ever produced, his standards are shaped by decades of success, discipline, and excellence.
When someone of his stature delivers such a damning verdict, it inevitably intensifies scrutiny on both the player involved and the club’s recruitment strategy.
The criticism feels even more cutting when placed against the optimism that surrounded the signing during the summer.
At the time of his arrival, expectations were extremely high. The club invested heavily, both in terms of the transfer fee and the player’s wages, while supporters were promised quality, experience, and leadership.
Many believed he would be a crucial component in Manchester United’s long-term rebuild — a player capable of raising standards and delivering consistency.
However, months into the season, that optimism has largely evaporated. The player has struggled to live up to the hype, failing to consistently influence matches or justify the financial outlay.
Performances have been erratic, confidence appears fragile, and critics argue he has been unable to cope with the physical demands, pressure, and intensity that come with wearing the United shirt.
For Scholes, those shortcomings are simply unacceptable at a club of Manchester United’s stature. Supporters have endured a series of underwhelming signings in recent years, but this one seems to strike a particularly painful nerve.
The frustration is not just about poor form — it reflects a deeper concern about ambition, standards, and whether the club is truly moving in the right direction.
In many ways, Scholes’ reported comments encapsulate the mood of a fanbase that is tired of false dawns and costly mistakes.
When a United legend publicly expresses regret over a signing and labels it the worst in club history, it underscores just how damaging the situation feels.
Whether the player can still turn things around remains to be seen, but for now, the criticism has firmly placed him at the centre of one of Old Trafford’s most uncomfortable debates.
