Following Manchester United’s surprising 3-1 defeat at home to Wolverhampton Wanderers, club icon Paul Scholes did not hold back in his critique of one of the team’s recent high-profile signings.
In his post-match analysis, Scholes openly questioned the rationale behind the club’s transfer decisions, suggesting that the acquisition in question may have been a significant misstep.
“I honestly don’t know why we signed him,” Scholes remarked, reflecting his frustration over what he perceived as a completely underwhelming performance.
The £43 million signing, intended to strengthen a key position in the squad, appeared to offer very little impact on the game, leaving both the former midfielder and fans puzzled about the justification for such an investment. Scholes emphasized that the issue goes beyond monetary value; it’s about the player’s contribution to the team.
“It’s not just about the money,” he stated. “It’s about what he brings to the squad—and right now, I see very little.”
Without initially naming the player, Scholes’ comments quickly sparked speculation among supporters and pundits, with many connecting the criticism to the high-profile recruit intended to replace a crucial figure in Manchester United’s setup.
Drawing direct comparisons to the predecessor, Scholes was blunt in highlighting the shortcomings of the new arrival: “He’s nowhere near the level of the player who had that position before him. Say what you like about that player, but at least you got consistency.
This one? I see no progression, no spark, and no impact.” His remarks suggested that the signing may not only have failed to improve the team but could have even weakened it in terms of performance and cohesion.
The defeat itself was a stark illustration of the squad’s ongoing struggles. Wolves, a side that has historically found it challenging at Old Trafford, arrived with confidence and quickly exploited a United team that appeared disorganized and lethargic.
Defensive mistakes, disjointed midfield play, and poor finishing compounded Manchester United’s difficulties, allowing the visitors to secure a convincing win.
The performance intensified scrutiny over the club’s transfer strategy and the pressure placed on incoming players to deliver results immediately.
Fans in the Theatre of Dreams expressed their dissatisfaction loudly, with boos resonating around the stadium.
Social media immediately reflected Scholes’ sentiments, with supporters questioning whether the £43 million signing was driven more by hype than a genuine tactical fit under Erik ten Hag’s system—or Ruben Amorim’s, depending on the ongoing managerial situation.
Many supporters argued that the team’s continued inconsistencies highlight the broader challenge of rebuilding Manchester United into a squad capable of competing consistently at the highest level.
Ultimately, Scholes’ post-match comments underscored a growing concern that certain high-profile signings have yet to justify their price tags and expectations.
As United continue to navigate their rebuild, both fans and club legends are demanding clarity, accountability, and meaningful performances from players brought in to strengthen the squad, signaling that patience is wearing thin.
